What Are Mutual Funds' Ratings Meaning: How CRISIL Ranks Funds

CRISIL also studies the portfolio itself. The parameters include risk-adjusted returns, asset quality, liquidity, and concentration of holdings across companies and industries.

What Are Mutual Funds' Ratings Meaning: How CRISIL Ranks Funds

When I speak with first-time investors, one question comes up almost every time: what are mutual funds, and how do I pick the right one? If you are still getting comfortable with the basics, this simple guide on what are mutual funds is a good place to begin. Once that foundation is in place, the real challenge is selection, because India has hundreds of schemes across equity, debt and hybrid categories. This is where fund ratings and rankings help.

Why Fund Ratings Matter

A mutual fund pools money from many investors and deploys it in stocks, bonds or other securities under a professional fund manager. Looking only at last year’s return can be misleading, since a fund may simply have ridden a favourable market. An independent rating or ranking offers a structured way to judge how a scheme has performed against comparable ones. In my experience, it works best as a screening tool that narrows the list, not as a final buying signal.

How CRISIL Ranks Mutual Funds

CRISIL, one of India’s best-known analytical firms, publishes the CRISIL Mutual Fund Ranking every quarter. The ranking is relative. A scheme is compared only with others in its peer group, such as a large-cap fund against other large-cap funds. Ranks run from 1 to 5:

  • Rank 1: top 10 percentile of the peer group, indicating very good performance
  • Rank 2: 11th to 30th percentile, indicating good performance
  • Rank 3: the middle band, indicating average performance
  • Rank 4: 71st to 90th percentile, indicating below-average performance
  • Rank 5: last 10 percentile, indicating relatively weak performance

What Goes Into the Ranking

What I value about this methodology is that it does not depend on NAV movement alone. CRISIL also studies the portfolio itself. The parameters include risk-adjusted returns, asset quality, liquidity, and concentration of holdings across companies and industries. A scheme that earned high returns by placing an outsized bet on a single stock or a weak-rated bond may therefore fail to secure a top rank.

Performance is assessed over several time periods, with more recent periods carrying greater weight. For debt schemes, credit quality and liquidity naturally receive closer attention. Equity schemes are judged more heavily on risk-adjusted returns.

How I Suggest You Read a Rank

A rank is useful only when interpreted correctly. These are the points I keep in mind:

  • Rank 1 is not a guarantee. It reflects past performance relative to peers, not a promise of future returns or freedom from risk.
  • Check consistency. Ranks are revised every quarter, so I prefer schemes that stay in the top two bands across several quarters instead of just one.
  • Compare within the category. A top-ranked small-cap fund and a top-ranked liquid fund carry very different risks, so their ranks cannot be placed side by side.
  • Look beyond the rank. Expense ratio, fund manager tenure, exit load, investment horizon and your own risk appetite matter just as much.

Final Thoughts

Ratings simplify a crowded market, but they cannot replace understanding. Knowing what are mutual funds, how they invest and what risks they carry remains the foundation of every sound decision. Use CRISIL’s ranking to shortlist, verify the details in the scheme documents, and align your choice with your financial goals.