Inside a Bay Lodge Hotel Stay — Rooms, Rates, and What's Included
On-site amenities extend beyond the rooms themselves. The property includes an indoor/outdoor pool ranging 3 to 5 feet deep, a hot tub, and SJ's Hideaway, a poolside bar.
John Smith-6 
Booking island lodging sight-unseen means relying heavily on what's actually included, since amenities vary widely between properties even at similar price points. Here's what a stay at a bay lodge hotel actually includes, based on the property's current offerings.
Standard rooms come in three configurations. Single King rooms include one king-size bed, a private bath, 40" TV with cable, mini-fridge, hairdryer, and free WiFi, well suited to couples. Double Queens offer the same amenities across two queen beds, with ADA-accessible options available. Triple Queens accommodate up to six adults and add a microwave to the standard amenity list, useful for groups wanting light in-room food prep.
For longer stays or larger groups, multi-bedroom suites step things up meaningfully. The two-bedroom suite sleeps six across two beds and a pull-out sleeper, with a full kitchen and separate living space. The two-bedroom split-level suite sleeps up to ten with a sleeping loft. The three-bedroom suite offers the most space, sleeping ten across five beds and a pull-out sleeper, with two bathrooms and a full kitchen with bar-top seating, a genuinely useful setup for large family groups or multi-couple trips.
On-site amenities extend beyond the rooms themselves. The property includes an indoor/outdoor pool ranging 3 to 5 feet deep, a hot tub, and SJ's Hideaway, a poolside bar. Pool hours run 8am to 10pm Sunday through Thursday and until 11pm on Fridays and Saturdays, seasonal and weather-dependent.
Golf cart rentals are available directly on-site, priced at $76/day for a 4-person cart and $97/day for a 6-person cart Sunday through Thursday, with weekend rates of $87 and $109 respectively. Since golf carts are the primary way most guests get around the island's 1,588 acres, having rental access at the hotel itself removes a logistical step many guests would otherwise need to arrange separately.
One important note: Ohio treats golf carts as licensed motor vehicles. Operators need a valid driver's license, must be 21 or older, and standard OVI and open-container laws apply exactly as they would on any road.
For anyone comparing a bay lodge hotel stay against other island options, matching room configuration to actual group size, and factoring in what's genuinely included versus what needs to be arranged separately, gives a much clearer picture of real value than rate alone.
