Which YouTube to MP3 Converter is Best? Top 5 Compared in Detail

In today’s digital world, streaming platforms like YouTube dominate entertainment. However, users often want to save their favorite songs, podcasts, or lectures offline in MP3 format. This is where YouTube to MP3 converter tools come in. With so many available online, choosing the right one can be confusing. This article offers a feature-to-feature comparison of five of the most popular tools: OnlyMP3, YTMP3, YT5s, MP3 Juice, and Tubidy.

User Interface and Ease of Use

OnlyMP3: Extremely clean, minimal, and clutter-free interface. Simply paste the YouTube link and download—no distractions.

YTMP3: Very simple, supports both MP3 and MP4, with clear options for beginners.

YT5s: Provides more options, including format and quality selection, but may look slightly complex for first-time users.

MP3Juice: Offers a built-in search bar to find music directly, but sometimes displays duplicate results.

Tubidy: Optimized for mobile users, with a straightforward layout perfect for quick searches and downloads.

Download Speed

OnlyMP3: This YouTube to MP3 converter is known for fast conversions, usually a few seconds per track.

YTMP3: YTMP3 is quick enough for single videos but slower with longer ones.

YT5s: It offers very fast downloads and supports bulk conversions.

MP3Juice: The Download speed of your YouTube videos depends on the source, but usually decent.

Tubidy: Moderate speed, optimized more for mobile browsing than instant downloads.

Supported Formats

OnlyMP3: OnlyMP3 is focused on MP3 audio conversion, but it also supports MP4 conversion.

YTMP3: This YouTube to MP3 converter supports MP3 and MP4 (basic options).

YT5s: It offers multiple formats for video conversion (MP3, MP4, 3GP, WEBM, etc.).

MP3Juice: MP3Juice converter mostly supports for MP3, but integrates streaming options.

Tubidy: Tubidy supports both YouTube to MP3 and MP4 conversion for mobile-friendly downloads.

Audio Quality

OnlyMP3: This converter tool maintains original quality up to 320kbps.

YTMP3: YTMP3 always provides a converted file with standard MP3 quality, usually 128kbps–192kbps.

YT5s: YT5s Downloader offers adjustable quality up to 320kbps audio and HD video.

MP3Juice: Quality varies depending on the source link.

Tubidy: Tubidy tool is good for casual listeners, but not always high fidelity.

Ads and Pop-Ups

OnlyMP3: Completely ad-free experience with a smooth interface.

YTMP3: Minimal ads, but mostly a clean interface for hassle-free experiences.

YT5s: Ad-heavy interface, can be distracting while downloading YouTube videos.

MP3Juice: This YouTube to MP3 Converter contains ads alongside music results.

Tubidy: Ads are present but less intrusive compared to other MP3 Converter tools.

Device Compatibility

OnlyMP3: This MP3 Converter works on all browsers, desktops, and mobile devices.

YTMP3: YTMP3 is fully compatible with both PC and mobile browsers.

YT5s: Works across all devices but performs best on desktop.

MP3Juice: MP3Juice is a mobile-friendly converter tool and works on all platforms.

Tubidy: This YouTube to MP3 Converter is specially optimized for mobile users.

Extra Features

OnlyMP3: OnlyMP3 is simple, fast, and secure, but no extras.

YTMP3: This YouTube to MP3 Converter tool offers both MP3 and MP4 downloads without extra tools.

YT5s: Advanced features like multiple resolutions, batch downloads, and subtitle options.

MP3Juice: The MP3Juice tool acts like a music search engine plus downloader.

Tubidy: Functions as both a streaming and downloading platform.

How to Use YouTube to MP3 Converter Tools?

Copy the YouTube Video Link

• Open YouTube in your browser or app.
• Find the video you want to convert to MP3.
• Copy the video’s URL from the address bar (or share > copy link on mobile).

Visit a YouTube to MP3 Converter Website

• Open any trusted converter tool like OnlyMP3, YTMP3, YT5s, Tubidy, or MP3Juice.
• Make sure the site is safe and doesn’t require unnecessary downloads.

Paste the Video URL

• In the converter’s input box, paste the copied YouTube link.
• Most tools detect the video automatically once you paste it.

Choose Output Format (MP3)

• Select MP3 as the preferred format (some tools also offer MP4 or other audio qualities).
• You may also be able to choose audio quality (e.g., 128kbps, 192kbps, 320kbps).

Start the Conversion

• Click on the Convert or Start button.
• The tool will process the video and prepare the MP3 file.

Download the MP3 File

• Once the conversion finishes, a Download button will appear.
• Click it to save the MP3 file on your device (computer, phone, or tablet).

Access Your File Offline

• Locate the MP3 file in your Downloads folder.
• You can now play it on any music player or transfer it to your mobile, USB, or other devices.

Conclusion

• For simplicity and no ads, Choose OnlyMP3.
• For basic MP3/MP4 downloads, YTMP3 is reliable.
• For multiple formats and quality options, YT5s stands out.
• For music discovery, MP3Juice offers built-in search.
• For mobile-first users, Tubidy is the best fit.

Each of these tools has its unique advantages. If you want speed and simplicity, OnlyMP3 is unbeatable. If you want feature-rich options, YT5s is worth trying. And if your focus is on music exploration, MP3Juice and Tubidy are strong contenders.